iFixit has taken apart Apple's new HomeView smart home display and concluded that the device is harder to repair than it should be, according to a report from MacRumors. The repair specialist said the teardown ended with damage to internal components.

Adhesive and mixed screws

MacRumors says iFixit found strong adhesive holding the HomeView's display in place, making it difficult to remove. Inside, the device uses a mix of Phillips and Torx screws in different sizes, so a technician needs several tools to reach the internal parts.

Most of the space behind the display is taken up by speakers, with the logic board sitting behind them. According to the report, the logic board has a shield that connects to the back of the aluminum enclosure, effectively turning the whole housing into a heat sink to help with thermal performance. Thermal paste and adhesive between the shield and the casing made the logic board hard to extract.

Speakers and two versions

The speakers are secured with a thick adhesive pad, and iFixit reportedly snapped one in half while trying to remove it. Several cables link the display to the speaker base. The teardown also found that the wall-mounted and tabletop versions of the HomeView are not built from interchangeable parts: the wall-mounted model uses a larger logic board, while the tabletop version has larger speakers and a pivot mount.

A bright spot at the base

Not everything was a struggle. iFixit found the speaker base follows a design similar to the HomePod and was easier to take apart. The USB-C port on the base is modular and replaceable, as are the two passive speakers inside the enclosure. However, because of how the HomeView is assembled, the display cannot be separated from the base without going in through the display side.

Repairability verdict

iFixit said Apple made several design choices that "made repairs unreasonably and unnecessarily difficult," and described the HomeView as a step backward in repairability compared with the HomePod, MacRumors reports.

The finding contrasts with Apple's recent moves on repair. Cupertino News reported earlier this week that Apple has added iPhone Duo parts and tools to its Self Service Repair Store, and Apple has published support guides covering HomeView repair options. Apple has not publicly responded to iFixit's teardown in the coverage reviewed, and it has not said whether HomeView parts will be added to its repair program.

The HomeView is now available, following Apple's launch announcement this month.

0 comments

Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.