Epic Games has asked a federal court to force Apple to hand over more than 122,000 documents tied to the commission Apple wants to charge on App Store purchases made through external payment links, according to a new filing reported by 9to5Mac.
Background
The dispute grows out of Epic's 2020 lawsuit against Apple. In 2021, Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers ordered Apple to let developers point users to payment methods outside the App Store. Apple later allowed external links but attached a commission of up to 27%, and the court found Apple in civil contempt of its injunction. Apple is still fighting that ruling, and the matter has reached the Supreme Court.
Separately, the district court is working out what commission, if any, Apple may charge on link-out purchases. Apple filed its proposal on August 13, suggesting rates between 5% and 15%. Epic is expected to respond once Apple finishes producing documents.
What Epic alleges
In the new filing, Epic says Apple has repeatedly failed to produce material explaining how it settled on those rates. Epic says that during the contempt proceedings Apple leaned on privilege claims to hold back documents, and that this time it is withholding them as irrelevant.
Epic's figures focus on seven people: four it says were involved in deciding the proposed fee, namely Tim Cook, Eddy Cue, Carson Oliver and Kevan Parekh, plus Nate Barton, Alex Roman and Phil Schiller. According to Epic, Apple has produced 632 custodial documents that matched the agreed search terms but is withholding more than 99% of the results, over 122,000 documents, as non-responsive. Epic also says the production lacks any substantive email on the proposed rates, notes from meetings where they were discussed, internal financial analysis, App Store profit and loss statements, or support for Apple's claim that its incremental link-out costs are essentially zero.
What Epic wants
Epic is asking the court to order Apple to produce every non-privileged document that matches the agreed search terms by December 2, 2026, whatever Apple considers relevant. Apple could still screen for attorney-client privilege, while Epic would decide what is relevant. Epic also asks for a daily monetary sanction for each day after December 2 that Apple does not comply, without proposing an amount.
What happens next
A hearing on the motion had been set for November 24 before Judge Gonzalez Rogers. According to the docket, as 9to5Mac describes it, a new order filed Tuesday that has not yet been made public refers the discovery dispute to a magistrate judge and terminates existing deadlines and hearings. The allegations are Epic's; Apple's response to this filing was not included in the report we reviewed.

0 comments