Epic Games has filed its response to Apple's Supreme Court appeal in the long-running App Store dispute, asking the justices to leave in place the lower court's finding that Apple was in civil contempt, 9to5Mac reports.
The case traces back to Epic's 2020 lawsuit after Fortnite was pulled from the App Store. The district court largely sided with Apple on the main claims but ordered that Apple could no longer stop developers from pointing users to payment options outside the App Store. Apple then allowed those links but attached a 27% commission to external purchases, along with rules on how buttons and links could be shown. The court later held that Apple had violated the original injunction.
According to the report, Apple appealed to the Supreme Court in May, and the court agreed in June to hear the case. Apple filed its opening brief in September. Its argument is that a court may find contempt only when an injunction clearly bars the specific conduct at issue, and that nothing in the original order explicitly prohibited a commission or additional link rules. The U.S. government filed a supporting brief that took a split view: it argued the injunction did not clearly prohibit the 27% commission, but that Apple was correctly held in contempt over limits on how developers display external payment buttons. Groups including the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and Chamber of Progress also filed briefs backing Apple.
In its response, Epic argues that Apple is proposing an extreme legal standard that would turn injunctions into what it calls a never-ending game of whack-a-mole. Epic contends that Apple chose the 27% rate knowing that, once developers' payment-handling costs of more than 3% were added, linked-out purchases would cost more than Apple's own in-app payments. It also says Apple tried to conceal its plan by asserting privilege over more than 57,000 documents, and it points to the district judge's finding that an Apple finance executive lied under oath about when the commission decision was made.
Epic asks the justices either to uphold the contempt ruling or, if they decide to clarify the legal standard for contempt, to send the case back to the lower courts to be reconsidered under that standard. These are Epic's claims as quoted in the report; Apple has made its own arguments in its filings.
The schedule from here: Apple has until December 14 to file its final brief, and oral arguments are set for January 11, 2027.
Apple has not changed the outcome for developers yet; the existing rulings remain the subject of the appeal while the case proceeds.

0 comments