A judge in British Columbia has allowed a class action against Apple to go forward, over claims that its search deal with Google held back competition and pushed up the price of search advertising. 9to5Mac reports that the Supreme Court of British Columbia certified the case.

The suit was filed in 2021 by Spark Event Rentals Ltd., a company based in the province. It argues that Apple and Google worked together to limit competition in search, which let Google charge advertisers inflated prices. Google was originally a defendant too, but the plaintiff later dropped it from the case after a dispute over an arbitration clause in its advertising contracts. Apple is now the only defendant.

What the plaintiff alleges

The central argument is that Apple could have used its resources and its distribution network to build a rival search engine, but chose not to because Google paid it billions of dollars in revenue-share payments to be the default search provider on Apple products. The class covers Canadian residents who bought search ads from Google since 2005, when the two companies first agreed to make Google the default on Safari in exchange for a share of ad revenue. The plaintiffs seek compensation for advertisers who they say overpaid, and the court has also let the question of punitive damages proceed.

Apple's position

According to the report, Apple has described the arrangement as a legitimate distribution agreement rather than an unlawful conspiracy. It has also argued that Google is the proper target and has called itself an "innocent bystander."

The role of the US antitrust case

Evidence from the US Justice Department's antitrust case against Google has become central to the Canadian suit. In that case a federal judge ruled in August 2024 that Google had illegally maintained its search monopoly through anticompetitive agreements, including its deal with Apple. Testimony from Apple executives Eddy Cue and John Giannandrea was presented there, and 9to5Mac says the Canadian judge cited it in his decision.

The judge, identified as Justice Thomas, also acknowledged Apple's objection that the plaintiff had selectively chosen evidence, but said that at this early stage of the proceedings it was appropriate to rely on it.

What happens next

The ruling does not find that Apple acted anticompetitively. It only lets the allegations be tested as a class action. No trial date has been announced.

The Google default-search arrangement has also drawn regulatory attention in the US, the UK and Australia, and related search-competition concerns have been examined in the EU and Japan, according to 9to5Mac.

0 comments

Sign in or create a free account to join the discussion.